The Harry Potter film series has been inevitably divergent from the books they share namesake with, it is simply too difficult to cram everything that occurs in the thick novels into a feature film and make it work. What the filmmakers, up to this point, have decided to do is to slim down the films to the more basic elements and present a streamlined version of events therein. For the most part this has worked, the films, while lacking some elements, capture the core of each book and create a Potter world almost no one could be disappointed with. The case of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince is no different, while the film differs significantly from book, leaving major portions out, the general feel and events are intact and this is what makes it a truly entertaining experience.
I must admit that it has been some time since I ventured into the Harry Potter world via the books so my knowledge of anything more than the basic plot may be lacking. What certainly is intact is the darker tone this book had, the film feels menacing from the opening sequence to the final scene, a tone that fits the source material quite well given Harry's attempts to discover more about Voldemort. The film also prominently features the coming of age of its main characters as Ron, Harry, and Hermoine all deal with relationship drama throughout. This aspect of the film is not as successful as the rest mainly due to the performances of the cast. While none of the actors or actresses are particuarly bad they all do a less than satisfactory job of portraying their characters conflicted emotions. This leaves the relationships feeling hollow and somewhat forced, a shame considering that these characters interactions drive the books and give them added appeal.
A film about wizards is always going to succeed or fail on the strength of its effects and Harry Potter is no different, the magic must look believable for the action to carry any weight. Fortunately, this has never been a problem for these films and has steadily improved since The Sorcerer’s Stone. In this film the effects become somewhat of a centerpiece as memory sequences are an important aspect of the plot. These sequences are fantastically done, as the black liquid memories become the buildings and people they represent it is impossible not to feel a sense of awe. The magic, as well, has improved as the battle between Harry and Draco as well as the one between Harry and Snape certainly have a sense of believability to them.
There are, however, two glaring omissions from the novel to film transition which may disappoint fans of the Rowling series. The two casualties are that of Dumbeldore’s funeral and the battle at Hogwart’s . These sequences are, for better or worse, completely removed. The Hogwart’s battle was most likely removed due to a similar battle occuring in the next film. As for Dumberldore’s funeral that may be used to establish tone in the next film and could open Deathly Hallows I.
What this film ends up being is one of the first, great, successes of the summer movie season. While it may lack some elements and have an uneasy feeling during the relationship scenes, Harry Potter and company still bring the magic and in the end that is what these films are all about. If you are a fan of the series or are looking for a magical adventure that will please across the board you can’t go wrong with Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince.
Score:8/10